The national case

The nutrition Pakistan pays for

Pakistan applies more fertiliser per acre of cropland than the world average. Only part of the nutrient applied reaches the crop. VAN’s view is that Pakistan needs to shift from applying more nitrogen to balancing the nutrients it applies and improving the form, timing and placement of fertiliser. The aim of this shift is to raise the yield per kg of nutrient applied. VAN bases this view on 2 sets of figures. First, in 2023, Pakistan applied more fertiliser nutrient per acre of cropland than the world average and more than the United States (FAO). Second, VAN’s calculation from national figures shows that, between 1999-2000 and 2023-24, nutrient applied per acre of arable land rose faster than the yields of wheat, rice and cotton and the average yield of all cereals. The yield per kg of nutrient applied therefore fell for wheat, rice, cotton and all cereals. VAN’s reading is that these figures do not support the view that farmers need to apply more fertiliser to raise yields. However, the figures cannot show the effect of fertiliser on its own, because seed, irrigation, varieties and weather also changed over these years.

Pakistan’s nitrogen use efficiency (NUE) was 29.1% in 2023 (an FAO estimate). The 29.1% means that Pakistan’s harvested crops contained about 29 kg of nitrogen for every 100 kg of nitrogen added to cropland in 2023. The 100 kg counts nitrogen from all sources, including fertiliser and manure. In 2023, world NUE was 55% and United States NUE was about 71% (FAO estimates). This article calls the 29 kg the nitrogen “taken out in the harvested crop”. The other 71 kg of every 100 kg added to Pakistan’s cropland were not taken out in the harvested crop. Part of this nitrogen came from fertiliser that farmers had bought and applied.

Punjab soil test data

Punjab's soil: 770,160 samples tested →
Most of Punjab's soil samples tested in about 2016 to 2018 were alkaline, with a pH above 7. On alkaline soil, part of the nitrogen applied is lost to the air. Alkaline soil also holds phosphorus and zinc in forms that the crop cannot take up. The soil page gives the results for each of Punjab's 36 districts.

← All knowledge · The state of the soil · Application systems

01Usage

Pakistan applies more fertiliser per acre than the world average

Fertiliser nutrient per acre of cropland

In 2023, Pakistan applied 63.3 kg of fertiliser nutrient per acre of cropland. Fertiliser nutrient means nitrogen, phosphate and potash together, counted as N, P₂O₅ and K₂O. The world average was 47.1 kg. Pakistan’s figure was 1.3 times the world average.

PakistanIndiaUKWorldUSA
196519701975198019851990199520002005201020152020020406080100120kg per acre of croplandIndia 73.7Pakistan 63.3UK 60.3World 47.1USA 43.6

Each line shows a country or the world average. Tap or hover over the chart to see every country in that year. Switch to "In 1 year" to see where Pakistan ranks among all countries and territories with data.

Source: FAO, Land, Inputs and Sustainability: Fertilizers by Nutrient, via Our World in Data (CC BY 4.0). Cropland is arable land plus land under permanent crops. The figures were converted from per hectare to per acre (1 acre = 0.4047 hectare).

In 2023, the United Kingdom applied 60.3 kg of fertiliser nutrient per acre of cropland and the United States 43.6 kg, both less than Pakistan’s 63.3 kg. Yet in 2023, cereal yields were about 72 maunds per acre in the United Kingdom and about 84 maunds per acre in the United States, against about 37 maunds per acre in Pakistan (FAO). In tonnes per hectare, the cereal yields were 7.1 in the United Kingdom, 8.3 in the United States and 3.6 in Pakistan. The fertiliser nutrient applied per acre is therefore not the main limit on Pakistan’s yields. Sections 3 to 5 show what happens to the nutrient after it is applied.

Of the countries shown when the chart opens, India applied the most fertiliser nutrient per acre of cropland in 2023, at 73.7 kg. Section 2 explains why India is a warning for Pakistan.

02Nutrient balance

The balance of nutrients in Pakistan’s fertiliser use

In 2023, nitrogen made up 78.5% of the fertiliser nutrient applied in Pakistan, phosphate 20.5% and potash 0.94%. A crop needs several nutrients besides nitrogen. The chart below compares Pakistan with India. India is Pakistan’s nearest large neighbour and grows similar crops on similar soils. India is shown as a warning for Pakistan. The note at the end of this section gives the reasons.

In 2023, potash was 0.94% of the fertiliser nutrient applied in Pakistan, against 6.13% in India

% of total nutrient applied · tap or hover over a segment
Nitrogen (N)Phosphate (P₂O₅)Potash (K₂O)
Pakistan78.5%20.5%0.94%India66.8%27.1%6.13%
For every 1 tonne of potash · Pakistan
83 t N · 22 t P₂O₅
Tonnes applied in 2023: N 3,808,775 t · P₂O₅ 994,885 t · K₂O 45,735 t
For every 1 tonne of potash · India
11 t N · 4 t P₂O₅
Tonnes applied in 2023: N 20,456,400 t · P₂O₅ 8,306,600 t · K₂O 1,878,600 t

Source · FAOSTAT, Fertilizers by Nutrient, via Our World in Data (2023). The ratios to 1 tonne of potash are VAN’s calculations. Sulfur, magnesium, zinc and boron are not shown, because the national figures record very little of them being applied.

VAN’s calculation from FAOSTAT shows that, in 2023, Pakistan applied 83 tonnes of nitrogen for every 1 tonne of potash. This ratio is the same as 1.2 kg of potash for every 100 kg of nitrogen. Potash fertiliser supplies the nutrient potassium. In the plant, potassium helps build cell walls, move sugars and regulate water use. Of all the nutrients, potassium does the most to protect a crop against lodging, heat and drought. Lodging means that the crop falls over. When a crop receives a lot of nitrogen and little potassium, and the soil cannot make up the shortfall in potassium, the crop’s growth is soft and easily damaged. Such a crop also cannot use all the nitrogen applied. The national ratio of 83 tonnes of nitrogen to 1 tonne of potash suggests that many crops in Pakistan receive too little potassium to use all the nitrogen applied.

Potash or phosphate applied per 100 kg of nitrogen

In 2023, Pakistan applied 1.2 kg of potash for every 100 kg of nitrogen. The world figure was 34.1 kg.

PakistanIndiaBangladeshChinaWorld
19651970197519801985199019952000200520102015202001020304050607080kg per 100 kg of nitrogenBangladesh 37China 35.9World 34.1India 9.2Pakistan 1.2

Each line shows how many kg of potash or phosphate a country applies for every 100 kg of nitrogen. A line near zero means that the country applies almost no potash or phosphate with its nitrogen.

Source: Calculated from FAO nutrient use per area of cropland, via Our World in Data (CC BY 4.0). The ratio is potash or phosphate divided by nitrogen, times 100. The ratio is the same per acre or per hectare.

Why India is a warning for Pakistan

India’s nutrient balance is not one for Pakistan to copy. Of the countries shown in section 1, India applied the most fertiliser nutrient per acre of cropland in 2023. India’s Twelfth Five Year Plan called the design of its nutrient subsidy “seriously flawed” because it distorted the balance between nutrients (Planning Commission of India, Twelfth Five Year Plan, Vol. II, para 12.37). The Comptroller and Auditor General of India found that, between 2010-11 and 2013-14, urea consumption in India rose slightly while consumption of muriate of potash fell sharply (CAG of India, Report No. 16 of 2015). Muriate of potash is the common potash fertiliser. Muriate of potash is also known as potassium chloride. The same report shows that, between 2010-11 and 2013-14, the potash price in India rose and the urea price did not. India has held the retail price of a 45 kg bag of urea at 242 Indian rupees since 1 March 2018 (Department of Fertilizers, Government of India).

Pakistan should not follow India’s path of raising fertiliser use. In India, a urea price that did not rise, at a time when the potash price rose, has led to higher fertiliser use and a worse balance between nutrients. The urea price that did not rise has not led to a higher yield per kg of nutrient applied in India. Pakistan’s balance between nutrients is already worse than India’s. In 2023, potash was 0.94% of the fertiliser nutrient applied in Pakistan, against 6.13% in India.

03Productivity

Yield per kg of nutrient applied in Pakistan, 1999-2000 to 2023-24

Between 1999-2000 and 2023-24, nutrient applied per acre of arable land in Pakistan rose by 68%, while wheat yield rose by 31%.

Nutrient applied per acre rose by 68% and wheat yield by 31% between 1999-2000 and 2023-24

1999-2000 → 2023-24

Nutrient applied per acre of arable land, 1999-2000 → 2023-24
38.6 → 64.9 kg/acre+68%
38.61999-200064.92023-24
kg/acre · World Bank
Wheat yield over the same period
25.2 → 33.0 maunds/acre+31%
25.21999-200033.02023-24
maunds/acre · Pakistan Economic Survey

The nutrient figures above are per acre of arable land. Arable land excludes land under permanent crops. These figures therefore differ from the cropland figures in section 1.

On an index with 1999-2000 = 100, nutrient applied per acre reached 168 and wheat yield 131 in 2023-24

index, 1999-2000 = 100
1001201401601801999-20002023-24+68% · nutrient+31% · wheat
168
Nutrient applied per acre of arable land, 1999-2000 → 2023-24 · 38.6 → 64.9 kg/acre (+68%) · World Bank
131
Wheat yield over the same period · 25.2 → 33.0 maunds/acre (+31%) · Pakistan Economic Survey

The chart joins the 2 published end years with a straight line. It does not show the years in between.

Source · The figures for nutrient applied per hectare of arable land come from World Bank series AG.CON.FERT.ZS (FAO). They were 95.4 kg/ha in the calendar year 2000 and 160.3 kg/ha in the calendar year 2023. VAN uses these figures for 1999-2000 and 2023-24. The crop yields come from Pakistan Economic Survey Table 2.5 (2009-10 and 2024-25 editions). The all-cereal yield comes from World Bank series AG.YLD.CREL.KG. The yields as published, in kg/ha for 1999-2000 and 2023-24, were 2,491 and 3,264 for wheat, 2,050 and 2,714 for rice, 641 and 717 for cotton lint, and 2,404 and 3,634 for all cereals. VAN converted the figures at 1 hectare = 2.471 acres and 40 kg = 1 maund. The change in yield per kg of nutrient applied, in the last column of the table, is VAN’s calculation.

For wheat, rice, cotton and cereals as a whole, yield rose less than nutrient applied per acre. The yield per kg of nutrient applied therefore fell for each of them.

Yield per kg of nutrient applied fell for wheat, rice, cotton and all cereals between 1999-2000 and 2023-24 (VAN’s calculation: 10% to 33%)

yield in maunds per acre · the last column is VAN’s calculation

Crop1999-20002023-24Yield changeChange in yield per kg of nutrient applied
Wheat25.233.0+31%−22%
Rice (cleaned basis)20.727.5+32%−21%
Cotton (lint)6.57.3+12%−33%
All cereals24.336.8+51%−10%
How the last column is calculated, and its limits

The last column shows the change in yield per kg of nutrient applied. Specialists call the yield per kg of nutrient applied partial factor productivity. VAN calculated the column by dividing the yield index by the index of nutrient applied per acre, with 1999-2000 = 100. The nutrient index uses the national figure for nutrient applied to all crops. Every row therefore uses the same nutrient index. The column does not compare the nutrient applied with the nutrient taken out in the harvested crop. The column shows the direction of the change. The column’s exact percentages should not be relied on.

The rice yield in this table is for cleaned rice. Cleaned rice is rice with the husk removed. Section 6 gives the rice yield as paddy.

Cereal grain per kg of fertiliser nutrient

By a rough indicator, Pakistan produced about 23 kg of cereal grain for each kg of fertiliser nutrient in 2023. The world figure was 36 kg.

PakistanIndiaBangladeshChinaWorld
1965197019751980198519901995200020052010201520201020301002003001,000kg of cereal grain per kg of fertiliser nutrientWorld 36Pakistan 23India 20China 19Bangladesh 15

This indicator divides cereal yield per acre (in kg) by the fertiliser nutrient applied per acre of all cropland. The result is the same whether it is worked out per acre or per hectare. The indicator does not come from crop trials. A change in the indicator over time does not measure the effect of fertiliser, because seed, irrigation, varieties and weather also changed over the same years. The yield response to nitrogen or phosphate can be measured only in field trials. Countries that apply very little fertiliser have very high values on this indicator. The vertical scale is therefore logarithmic. On this scale, 10 to 100 takes the same space as 100 to 1,000.

Source: Calculated from FAO cereal yield and FAO fertiliser nutrient use per area of cropland, via Our World in Data (CC BY 4.0).

04Where nitrogen goes

Where the nitrogen added to Pakistan’s cropland goes

NUE, Pakistan and other countries

In 2023, Pakistan's NUE was 29.1%. World NUE was 55.3%. In Pakistan, about 71 of every 100 kg of nitrogen added were not taken out in the harvested crop.

PakistanIndiaUSABangladeshChina
19651970197519801985199019952000200520102015202001020304050607080NUE, %USA 71.4China 47.3India 43Bangladesh 40.3Pakistan 29.1

The figures in this chart are FAO estimates. The figure for China covers mainland China only. In these estimates, the nitrogen added to cropland includes nitrogen from all sources: fertiliser, manure, fixation by legumes, rain and dust, and seed. NUE counts only the part of this nitrogen that is taken out in the harvested crop. The nitrogen not taken out in the harvested crop is removed in straw and stalks, is lost to the air or lost to water, or is not accounted for in FAO’s estimate. Because NUE counts only the nitrogen in the harvested crop, NUE is a different measure from the nitrogen “taken up” by the crop. Nitrogen taken up by the crop means nitrogen absorbed by the plant.

Source: FAOSTAT, Cropland Nutrient Balance, December 2025 release (FAO estimates). Because NUE is a percentage, NUE is the same whether it is worked out per acre or per hectare.

How nitrogen is lost from the soil, and how alkaline soil binds phosphorus and zinc

Part of Pakistan’s nitrogen loss is caused by the chemistry of its soil. Farmers cannot control this soil chemistry. In Punjab, 69.1% of the 770,160 soil samples tested in about 2016 to 2018 had an alkaline pH above 8.0 (section 5). On such soil, urea left on the surface breaks down quickly to ammonia. This breakdown is called hydrolysis. Part of the nitrogen in the ammonia is lost to the air before the crop can take it up. The nitrogen that remains in the soil is converted to nitrate. Part of that nitrate moves with the irrigation water and is lost to water. In waterlogged soil, part of the nitrate is converted to nitrogen gases and lost to the air. This process is called denitrification. In alkaline soil, phosphorus and zinc also form calcium and carbonate compounds that the root cannot take up. High soil pH therefore causes 2 problems. It increases the loss of applied nitrogen. It also makes phosphorus and zinc in the soil less available to the crop.

NUE in Pakistan

Pakistan’s NUE was 29.1% in 2023 (an FAO estimate)

Of every 100 kg of nitrogen added to Pakistan’s cropland in 2023, 29 kg were taken out in the harvested crop (FAO). The 29 kg and 100 kg figures cover all crops in Pakistan together. FAO estimates that, of the same 100 kg, about 26 kg were lost to the air and 11 kg were lost to water. Part of this lost nitrogen came from fertiliser that farmers had paid for. The crop never received this nitrogen. A further part of the 100 kg was taken off the field in straw and stalks. The remainder is not accounted for. By comparison, NUE in the United States was about 71% in 2023.

Source · FAOSTAT, Cropland Nutrient Balance, December 2025 release (2023, FAO estimates). Shahzad et al. (2019), Nature Sustainability, ranks Pakistan lowest in its comparison set for nitrogen use efficiency as the study measures it.

Why the nitrogen is lost

Part of the loss is caused by soil conditions that the farmer cannot change.

About 69% of the samples in the Punjab soil testing programme, taken about 2016 to 2018, had a pH above 8.0. On such soil, part of the nitrogen in urea left on the surface turns to ammonia and is lost to the air before the crop can take it up. The same high pH also affects phosphate and zinc in calcareous soil. Calcareous soil is soil rich in calcium carbonate. In such soil, free calcium binds most of the phosphate applied. Zinc in such soil also becomes unavailable to the crop.

Punjab soil testing programme: 770,160 samples →
Part of the loss comes from application practices that the farmer can change.

How much nitrogen is lost also depends on where the fertiliser is placed, how the doses are split, whether irrigation follows the application, and what the fertiliser is mixed with.

Steps a farmer can take to reduce the loss

  1. 1Change to a coated urea.Ordinary urea releases all its nitrogen at once when it lands on hot soil. A coated urea releases its nitrogen over several days. A coated urea costs more than ordinary urea. This step is listed first because it has the largest effect. VAN bases this order on its own field trials, data and field experiments with coated urea. Published research also shows that urea which releases its nitrogen slowly loses less ammonia. In a meta-analysis of 120 studies on maize, controlled-release urea applied at the same rate as ordinary urea cut ammonia loss by 39.4% (Zhang et al. 2019).
  2. 2If you keep the same fertiliser, change how you apply it.When the same fertiliser is placed in a band beside the seed row, drilled at sowing, or side-dressed and then irrigated, more of its nitrogen reaches the crop than when it is broadcast on dry alkaline soil. Broadcasting means spreading fertiliser over the soil surface. Side-dressing means placing fertiliser beside the growing crop. When the farmer changes only the method, the bag and the price stay the same.Placement also matters for phosphate fertiliser, including diammonium phosphate (DAP). The closer a phosphate fertiliser is placed to the root, the less of it the soil binds before the root reaches it.The 5 application methods and what each one changes →
  3. 3If you apply fertiliser through the irrigation water, level the field first.Applying fertiliser through the irrigation water is called fertigation. On unlevelled ground, the water and everything dissolved in it reach the low end of the field first and the high end late or not at all. On a level field, fertigation spreads the nutrient more evenly than on unlevelled ground. This more even spread comes from levelling the field.
  4. 4Change the timing: split the nitrogen into doses.If all the nitrogen is applied in 1 early dose, much of it sits in the soil before the crop needs it. Nitrogen that sits in the soil can be lost. Split the nitrogen into doses that follow the crop’s own demand. Time each dose with an irrigation.
  5. 5Prepare the tank mix correctly.A correctly prepared tank mix helps the crop take up more of what is sprayed on the leaves or applied through the irrigation water. Most of the method is covered by these 4 rules.Fill the tank half full of water first. Keep the agitator running. Add products 1 at a time. Let each product disperse before adding the next. Adding products to an empty tank, or all at once, makes a mix curdle.Add products in order of how hard each is to disperse: wettable powders, then water-dispersible granules, then suspensions and flowables, then anything already in solution, then emulsifiable concentrates, and adjuvants and surfactants last of all.Jar-test any mix you have not made before. Mix the same products in the same order and at the same ratio in a clear jar. Leave the jar for 15 minutes. If the mix curdles, or forms flakes, a layer on top or sludge at the bottom, the mix will do the same in a 200-litre tank and block the boom.Spray the mix on the day you make it, in the early morning or late afternoon. A mix left standing separates. In the heat of the middle of the day, a leaf takes up far less, because the small pores on its surface close. These pores are called stomata.These are general spray rules. They do not show which VAN brands can be mixed together. VAN’s agronomy team answers, brand by brand, which VAN brands must not share a tank, at what concentration, and how your own water affects them. Companies that partner with VAN receive the full answers.

Steps 2, 3, 4 and 5 cost nothing. A farmer who changes only where and when the existing fertiliser is applied gets more of its nitrogen to the crop without buying an extra bag.

A separate VAN report sets out what this nitrogen loss costs and how Pakistan can raise its NUE. The report shows where the 5.7 million tonnes of nitrogen added to Pakistan’s cropland from all sources in 2023 went (an FAO estimate). It also shows how other countries raised their NUE. The cost of low nitrogen use efficiency in Pakistan →

05Punjab soil

Punjab’s soil test results

Most of Punjab’s 770,160 soil samples, tested in about 2016 to 2018, were alkaline. A soil with a pH above 7 is alkaline. The mean pH of the samples, weighted by the number of samples in each district, was 8.22. 7 samples in 10 were above pH 8.0. Only 979 samples were below pH 7. A pH of 7 is the neutral point.

8.22
mean pH
all 770,160 samples, weighted by the number of samples in each district
96.1%
above pH 7.5
69.1% above 8.0 · 17.8% above 8.5
0.61%
mean organic matter
90.2% of samples below 0.86%, Punjab’s threshold for low organic matter
97.9%
of samples below 15 parts per million (ppm) of available phosphorus, the adequate level
59.1% below 7 ppm, the deficiency threshold

Source · Punjab soil testing programme · 36 district workbooks · 770,160 valid samples · tested in about 2016 to 2018 · Read the limits of this data before quoting it ›

In these samples, available phosphorus did not fall as pH rose. The soil page explains this pattern by past fertiliser use. The most alkaline districts are also the most heavily fertilised. Controlled studies have established that alkaline soil binds phosphorus. This binding does not show in the data of the Punjab soil testing programme.

06Other countries

Yield per kg of nutrient applied in other countries

Some countries have a higher yield per kg of nutrient applied than Pakistan. Some countries have also raised their yield per kg of nutrient applied over time, by different methods and at different scales. By contrast, India produced less paddy per kg of nitrogen applied to rice than Pakistan, in the rice comparison below. Paddy is rice still in its husk.

Rice: paddy produced per kg of nitrogen in 6 Asian countries

This comparison uses 1 crop grown in 1 region and 1 measure: the paddy produced for each kg of nitrogen applied to rice.

Bangladesh produced 56.8 kg of paddy per kg of nitrogen applied to rice and Pakistan 33.7 kg, on nitrogen rates for 2017-18 and paddy yields for 2023 (VAN’s calculation)

kg of paddy per kg N
Bangladesh56.8Vietnam47.9China40.2Pakistan33.7Thailand32.3India31.8

Source · N rates: International Fertilizer Association (IFA) Fertilizer Use by Crop 2017/18, via Ludemann, Gruère, Heffer & Dobermann (2022), Scientific Data 9. Paddy yields: FAOSTAT via Our World in Data (2023). Farm size: Pakistan Bureau of Statistics (PBS) 7th Agricultural Census 2024 (Pakistan); Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (BBS) Agricultural Census 2019 (Bangladesh), via FAO World Programme for the Census of Agriculture 2020 (WCA-2020). Paddy per kg N is VAN’s calculation. The source figures were published per hectare. Nitrogen applied, in kg/ha, was: Bangladesh 91.8, Vietnam 127.6, China 177.6, Pakistan 120.6, Thailand 92.5, India 135.4. Paddy yields, in t/ha, were 5.21, 6.11, 7.14, 4.07, 2.99 and 4.31, in the same order. VAN converted them at 1 hectare = 2.471 acres and 40 kg = 1 maund.

CountryN applied to rice (survey estimate)Paddy yieldPaddy per kg NAverage farm size
Bangladesh37.2 kg/acre52.7 maunds/acre56.8 kg1.29 acres
Vietnam51.6 kg/acre61.8 maunds/acre47.9 kg
China71.9 kg/acre72.2 maunds/acre40.2 kg
Pakistan48.8 kg/acre41.2 maunds/acre33.7 kg5.3 acres
Thailand37.4 kg/acre30.3 maunds/acre32.3 kg
India54.8 kg/acre43.6 maunds/acre31.8 kg

On VAN’s calculation, Bangladesh produced 68% more paddy per kg of nitrogen applied to rice than Pakistan.

Bangladesh is a useful comparison for Pakistan. Its farms are smaller than Pakistan’s, at 1.29 acres on average (2019 census) against 5.3 acres (2024 census). The 2 countries have the same monsoon. Bangladesh’s paddy yield rose from 34.4 maunds per acre in 2000 to 52.7 maunds per acre in 2023 (FAOSTAT, published as 3.40 and 5.21 t/ha). In 2017-18, Bangladesh applied less nitrogen per acre to rice than Pakistan. These facts lead VAN to the view that farm size does not explain Bangladesh’s higher output of paddy per kg of nitrogen applied to rice. VAN’s interpretation is that nutrient balance, rice varieties and the way nutrient is applied explain it.

Limits of this comparison · The nitrogen rates are survey estimates for the 2017-18 season. The paddy yields are for 2023. Recalculating both on a same-year 2018 basis changes the values. The ranking stays the same on that basis. Bangladesh and Vietnam still produced more paddy per kg of nitrogen than Pakistan, and India still produced less. Myanmar is left out because it applies so little nitrogen to rice that its paddy per kg of nitrogen is very high even though its yields are low.

China and the United States

China

On VAN’s calculation from FAO and World Bank data, China’s total fertiliser nutrient use fell by 22.6% between 2014 and 2023, while its cereal yield rose by 8.9%. China issued a national programme in 2015 to stop the growth in fertiliser nutrient use. China’s total fertiliser nutrient use had already peaked in 2014. The programme therefore reinforced a fall that had begun before the programme was issued.

United States

On VAN’s calculation from World Bank and FAO data, the cereal production of the United States rose by 35% between 2000 and 2023, while its total fertiliser nutrient use rose by about 1%. On VAN’s calculation, United States cereal production per kg of fertiliser nutrient used rose from 20.8 kg in 2000 to 27.8 kg in 2023. The 2023 figure was 2.5 times Pakistan’s figure of about 11 kg on the same measure. This measure divides total cereal production by total fertiliser nutrient used. It therefore differs from the 23 kg of cereal grain per kg of fertiliser nutrient in section 3. That indicator divides cereal yield per acre by fertiliser nutrient applied per acre of all cropland.

The cases in this section point to 4 ways of raising the yield per kg of nutrient applied.

Balance

Balance means applying all the nutrients a crop needs instead of mainly nitrogen. Balance also means crop-specific formulations based on soil tests, in place of a single blend for every crop.

Uptake

Uptake means getting the crop to take up more of the nutrient applied.

Timing

Timing means splitting the nutrient into several applications timed to the crop’s demand, instead of applying most of it early in the season.

Placement

Placement means using deep placement, banding and fertigation instead of broadcasting fertiliser on the surface. These methods place the nutrient near the root, away from where it is easily lost.

In 2023-24, China still applied about 2.5 times as much fertiliser nutrient per acre of arable land as Pakistan, at 159 kg against 65 kg (World Bank, published as 394 and 160 kg/ha). The lesson from China is therefore about raising the yield per kg of nutrient applied while China’s fertiliser nutrient use per acre remains high.

Source · World Bank AG.PRD.CREL.MT and AG.YLD.CREL.KG (FAO); FAOSTAT nutrient use via Our World in Data. The changes and the per-kg figures are VAN’s calculations.

07Application

How a nutrient is applied

The same quantity of a nutrient has different effects depending on its form, the time it is applied and the way it is placed. For example, urea broadcast on the surface of hot alkaline soil loses part of its nitrogen to the air as ammonia. The same nitrogen in a coated form is released over days. Less of the coated nitrogen is therefore exposed to loss at any one time. Timing changes the effect of a nutrient in the same way. A micronutrient spray adds to yield only when it is applied at the growth stage at which the crop needs it. At the wrong stage, the spray adds cost without adding yield.

In Pakistan, fertiliser is bought by the bag and by the nutrient percentage printed on it. The bag and the percentage printed on it do not tell the farmer when or how to apply the nutrient. These choices affect how much of the nutrient is lost.

The 5 application methods and what each one changes →
08What VAN makes for each problem

What each problem needs, and the VAN brands that address it

VAN’s brands and its published crop plans address the 5 problems described in sections 2 to 7. The table below lists what each problem needs and the VAN brands for it. VAN’s own laboratory tests every batch of each brand listed before the batch is released. The Pakistan National Accreditation Council (PNAC) accredits the laboratory. According to VAN’s record of its licences from the Pakistan Standards and Quality Control Authority (PSQCA), 20 of VAN’s 23 registered brands held a PSQCA manufacturing licence in July 2026.

ProblemWhat is neededVAN brands
BalanceThe nutrition plan includes potash, sulfur, magnesium, calcium and micronutrients from the start.Vital Potash · SOP · Green Sulfur · V-Mag Essential · Cala-Mag V · V-Zinc · VL-Boron · VL-Micromix
Nitrogen lossOn soil where plain urea loses nitrogen to the air as ammonia, the nitrogen must stay in the soil long enough for the crop to take it up.Vital Urea is sulfur-coated and patented. Once water reaches the granule, its nitrogen is released in steps over days.
Phosphorus and zinc bound by alkaline soilLocal, temporary acidification around the roots may help the crop take up phosphorus and zinc that alkaline soil has bound.The sulfur coating on Vital Urea · Green Sulfur · Humi Grow · V-Transform
Stage mismatchA crop plan sets what to apply, at which growth stage and at what rate, in place of a single bag for the whole season.VAN has published 28 crop plans, each set out by growth stage.
Application methodThe product form suits the way the nutrient is applied: fertigation, foliar spray, drone spraying, broadcasting or side-dressing.VAN makes water-soluble, liquid and foliar grades across its range.
VAN brands for each soil condition →
09Evidence

How to read the evidence

The figures in sections 1 to 6 come from public sources: national and international statistics, and the Punjab soil testing programme. Ratios and indices are VAN’s calculations from those figures.

Peer-reviewed studies show that coated and controlled-release nitrogen reduces nitrogen losses compared with uncoated urea (Zhang et al. 2019). Coated and controlled-release nitrogen also raises the share of fertiliser nitrogen taken up by the crop (Zhang et al. 2019; Zhu et al. 2020). Peer-reviewed studies also show that elemental sulfur raises phosphorus availability in calcareous soil. These findings are about the technologies in general. They are not measurements made on VAN’s brands.

On request, VAN shares the results of any trial it holds on a specific VAN brand.

10Sources

Sources of every figure

FigureSourceYear
Fertiliser use per hectare of cropland (shown per acre)Our World in Data / FAO2023 data, 2025 release
Nutrient use per hectare of arable land (shown per acre)World Bank AG.CON.FERT.ZS (FAO source)2000 and 2023 (used for 1999-2000 and 2023-24)
N, P₂O₅, K₂O tonnagesFAOSTAT Fertilizers by Nutrient, via Our World in Data2023
Crop yieldsPakistan Economic Survey Table 2.5 (2009-10 and 2024-25 editions)1999-2000 and 2023-24
All-cereal yield and productionWorld Bank AG.YLD.CREL.KG · AG.PRD.CREL.MT (FAO)2000 to 2023
NUEFAOSTAT, Cropland Nutrient Balance, December 2025 release1961 to 2023
Nitrogen surplus, partial factor productivityShahzad et al., Nature Sustainability2019
Controlled-release urea: ammonia loss and nitrogen taken up by the cropZhang, Liang, He et al., Environmental Pollution 246:559-565; Zhu, Liu, Xu, Yang and Shi, PLoS ONE 15:e02414812019; 2020
India: nutrient subsidy designPlanning Commission of India, Twelfth Five Year Plan, Vol. II, para 12.372013
India: urea and potash consumptionComptroller and Auditor General of India, Report No. 16 of 20152015
India: urea retail priceDepartment of Fertilizers, Government of India2018 onwards
Punjab soil testing programmePunjab soil testing programme · 36 district workbooks · 770,160 valid samples · tested in about 2016 to 2018about 2016 to 2018
Nitrogen applied to riceIFA Fertilizer Use by Crop, via Ludemann, Gruère, Heffer & Dobermann (2022), Scientific Data 92017-18
Paddy yieldsFAOSTAT, via Our World in Data2000 and 2023
Average farm sizePBS 7th Agricultural Census (Pakistan); BBS Agricultural Census via FAO WCA-2020 (Bangladesh)2024; 2019

Derived figures are VAN’s calculations from the published figures shown. Section 1 and the country charts in section 3 use cropland. Cropland is arable land plus land under permanent crops. The index chart and table in section 3, and the China comparison in section 6, use arable land. In the country lists, “Excluded territory” stands for (A Territory Excluded per Passport Directive).

Questions that the charts do not answer

On VAN’s WhatsApp enquiry line, VAN’s agronomy team answers questions that the charts on this page do not answer.

Ask on WhatsApp